6 May 2001
Could Zoe's dad be innocent?
New investigation queries stepfather's
conviction for murder of nine-year-old
By Amelia Hill, John Ashton and Evans's mother, Sandra
Vital evidence not heard during one of the most notorious
child murder cases in recent years could prove that the man convicted of
the crime is innocent and the true killers are still at large, according
to a fresh investigation.
Nine-year-old Zoe Evans disappeared from her home
in Warminster, Wiltshire, in the early hours of 11 January 1997 after being
tucked up for the night by her mother, Paula.
Despite launching Britain's biggest search for a
missing person, it took police six and a half weeks to find Zoe's body,
in a badger sett less than half a mile from her home.
The post-mortem found that the child had died from
asphyxiation - her T-shirt was pushed into her mouth to stop her screaming.
Miles Evans, Zoe's stepfather, who was 27 at the
time of the disappearance, was arrested five days after her disappearance
when his bloodied T-shirt was found close to the burial scene. Two weeks
later, the former soldier was charged with murder.
Evans has always protested his innocence and, although
the Court of Appeal announced last week that it would consider his case,
he has continued to insist on a full retrial to clear his name.
According to new evidence to be revealed this week,
a retrial may prove that Evans could not have murdered Zoe. The investigation
points to two other possible suspects whose names were withheld from the
original trial because of lack of evidence. It will attempt to prove that
Zoe's body was only placed in the badger sett a few days before it was
discovered by police; if successful, it could clear Evans's name.
'The prosecution claimed the six-week delay was because
the body was originally fully buried and was only later pulled out by animals,'
said Steve McDonnell, editor of the Meridian Television Focus programme,
to be screened this week.
But five weeks before the body was discovered, a
team of Metropolitan Police officers with dogs trained to search for bodies
was told not to look in the area around the badger sett, because it had
already been searched.
'Evans's movements from the morning after Zoe's disappearance
were fully accounted for,' added Ashton. 'So, if the body was put there
after that point, he could not have been responsible for the murder.'
The investigation also found that two youths seen
roaming around Warminster on the night of Zoe's disappearance, who were
later accused of raping a young woman that same night, could have been
near Zoe's home at the time she disappeared.
One, identified as Youth A, had a conviction for
indecent assault. When questioned by police shortly after the murder, he
denied knowing Zoe but later changed his evidence, conceding that he was
familiar with the child because she was a schoolfriend of his sister.
The new investigation has also uncovered two witnesses
who did not appear in the original trial. They say they saw two men, one
bearing a close similarity to Youth A, disposing of a full bin liner in
bushes the morning after Zoe's disappearance.
'The men were acting very suspiciously,' said Loretta
Pritchard, a local hairdresser. 'They had a bin liner that they were trying
to deposit in the trees and one was walking off while the other was looking
around, making sure that no one was watching them.'
She reported her sighting to the police but a brief
search by an individual officer found nothing. Five days later, however,
Pritchard saw someone resembling Youth A for a second time. 'He came back
and deposited something else in the same place,' she said. 'He was very
furtive.'
Mike Schwarz, Miles Evans's lawyer, said: 'Evidence
has now come to light that poses serious questions about the movements
and activities of Youths A and B on the night of Zoe's murder. The jury
should have heard about those questions and, if they had done, they might
have had another account consistent with Miles Evans's innocence.'
Evans's mother, Sandra, maintains her belief in her
son's innocence. 'It takes a very clever person to lie for four years and
to keep that lie going and not to crack,' she said. 'I'm his mother and
I can say that he's not the brightest person but he has not changed his
story from the day he was arrested. That takes a clever person. And I don't
think he would be able to do it.' |